The Biggest Lie About Weight Loss and Cycling

The internet is awash with claims that exercise doesn’t help with weight loss. This assertion, often presented in viral videos and podcasts, is the biggest lie about weight loss and cycling. While it may seem appealing or even credible at first glance, it’s a gross oversimplification that can mislead people into undervaluing the role of exercise in achieving and maintaining a healthy weight. Let’s explore why this claim is so misleading and unpack the science behind it.

The Biggest Lie About Weight Loss and Cycling: Exercise Doesn’t Help

Many experts and influencers argue that exercise has little to no impact on weight loss, citing studies that show modest results. For instance, respected scientist Professor Tim Spector stated on a popular podcast that long-term studies indicate exercise doesn’t contribute to weight loss. While this claim may contain a kernel of truth, it neglects the bigger picture.

Systematic reviews and meta-analyses, such as those published in Nature, reveal that exercise groups consistently experience greater weight loss than non-exercise groups. These studies show an average weight loss of 1.5 to 3.5 kilograms, primarily from fat. Though modest, these findings debunk the claim that exercise has no effect on weight loss. Additionally, the studies that downplay exercise’s role often involve limited activity levels, far less than the rigorous training of dedicated cyclists or athletes.

Why the Biggest Lie About Weight Loss and Cycling Persists

A significant reason for this misconception lies in the constrained energy model proposed by researcher Hermann Ponser. This model suggests that the body compensates for increased physical activity by conserving energy elsewhere, such as through reduced fidgeting or downregulated biological processes. While this explains why extreme levels of exercise don’t always yield proportional weight loss, it doesn’t negate the benefits of regular, consistent physical activity.

For example, amateur cyclists who engage in long rides burning 2,500 to 3,500 calories per session can achieve significant weight loss, provided they maintain a balanced diet. The key is volume and consistency. Most studies cited by skeptics involve low exercise volumes—typically under 150 minutes per week—and fail to replicate the effects of sustained, high-intensity training.

The Real Benefits of Cycling Beyond Weight Loss

Even if exercise had no direct impact on weight loss, cycling offers a myriad of health benefits that make it indispensable:

• Improved cardiovascular health: Cycling reduces the risk of heart disease, the leading cause of death worldwide.
• Enhanced metabolic health: Regular cycling improves blood sugar regulation and insulin sensitivity.
• Increased muscle mass: Particularly in the legs, cycling builds strength and endurance.
• Mental health benefits: Cycling is therapeutic, confidence-building, and often a highly social activity.

These advantages contribute to overall well-being, underscoring why exercise should remain a cornerstone of a healthy lifestyle.

Debunking the Myth: A Balanced Approach

The biggest takeaway from this discussion is that weight management isn’t about choosing between diet and exercise; it’s about combining the two. You can’t out-train a poor diet, but you also shouldn’t underestimate the role of exercise in improving body composition and overall health.

Elite cyclists and endurance athletes illustrate what’s possible with consistent, high-volume training. While most people won’t match the output of a Tour de France competitor, finding an enjoyable form of exercise, like cycling, and pairing it with a healthier diet can yield impressive results over time.

Final Thoughts on the Biggest Lie About Weight Loss and Cycling

The idea that exercise doesn’t help with weight loss is not just misleading but potentially harmful. It discourages people from embracing a lifestyle that could significantly improve their physical and mental health. The truth is that while diet is the most critical factor in weight management, exercise plays a vital supporting role. Cycling, in particular, is a powerful tool for enhancing health, building confidence, and, yes, aiding in weight loss.

Don’t let oversimplified claims deter you from pursuing a balanced approach to fitness and nutrition. Combine regular exercise with a diet low in ultra-processed foods, and you’ll set yourself up for sustainable success.

Want to learn how you can finally lose weight, keep it off and stop getting dropped on climbs without having to sacrifice your favourite foods and starve yourself on some crazy calorie-restricting diet …even if they’ve failed in the past or struggled to improve your cycling performance. Click here to watch this free, on-demand online training.

Ready to elevate your cycling performance? Book a free call with me to discuss whether you are a good fit for my coaching program and how I can create a personalised coaching plan to help you achieve your goals.